I must say, I had absolutely no intention of writing this blog post. I bought Charlotte Tilbury’s Magic Foundation after a long time dithering over whether I really needed another one (I already have a wardrobe of five I use on a regular basis). I had a voucher, there was 10% off, you know how it is girls. Thing is, I just can’t get on with it. I actually kind of hate it. Am I the only one?
By now you have probably read about 25 blog posts extolling the virtues of this foundation – apparently it’s the best thing since sliced bread. And I was SO ready to love it. But it just doesn’t match up to the pure joy of Estée Lauder’s Double Wear.
I wanted to give the Magic Foundation a fair go, so I tried it with a whole range of bases and applications to see how it stacked up. It’s probably worth pointing out I have combination skin that I think is maybe a bit dehydrated at the moment.
Application
First I tried the Magic Foundation with my usual primer and applied with my fingers. Exactly how I apply all my other foundations.
Here is me with just the foundation on (#nofilter – I just tried to blur out my messy bedroom in the background!):
And here I am (looking slightly happier) with the rest of my make up on (still #nofilter):
I tried a different primer.
I tried applying with a beauty blender.
I tried applying with a brush.
I tried it with powder on top.
I tried it with powder foundation on top.
But the results, with varying degrees of intensity, have all been the same!
Wear
Every single day I have worn the Magic Foundation, it has become patchy around my nose, stuck into the wrinkles under my eyes and lodged itself into the creases between my eyes and from my nose to the corners of my mouth. In the picture below, you can see how it has become patchy around a lovely spot I had and gathered into shiny clumps on my nose.
The coverage is nowhere near as full as Double Wear and I find I need a lot of product (two pumps) per application to get a full face worth.
I did my best to get a picture of my worn out face, but the light in winter is BAD and it’s not the most flattering angle. Again, no filter on this one! (Sexy).
Would I Buy It Again?
The only reason I haven’t put this on depop to sell is because it only worked out costing me £6.50 so it’s comparable to what I would spend on a similar day to day foundation that’s a bit rubbish. And that’s exactly what I’ll be using it for – day to day in the office, when I’m not too bothered about it looking rather worse for wear come 5pm.
The one thing I will give it is that the colour is perfect for my skin tone. I wear shade #4.
As soon as it runs out, it will be consigned to the bin, never to be bought again! Sorry Charlotte, the Magic Foundation just didn’t cut it for me.
Have you got the Magic Foundation? What did you think?
♥ JH
Gemma says
OMG YES Helen! Thank god someone else is saying the same thing as me! I found this foundation a total disappointment never mind talking about how much they are asking for it! I
hellojenniferhelen says
Such a disappointment wasn’t it! I am still disappointed by it now (wearing it for work to use it up!)
? JH
CAT CULMER says
I went to the Charlotte Tilbury counter to sample and buy this and was advised it was aimed at younger skin – I’m 32 not 72! I’ve stuck with double wear
Cat
hellojenniferhelen says
Oh my gosh that is so rude! I’m 30 and I’d say it’s aimed exactly at women our age!
? JH
Sam | North East Family Fun says
Oh no! Imagine you’d paid full price! This is a product i’ll definitely avoid then x
hellojenniferhelen says
I know, I’m glad I didn’t!
? JH
Alice Fairweather says
Your skin looks glowing! Great review, I’m going to invest! x
hellojenniferhelen says
The glow didn’t last long! I’d recommend investing in Double Wear!
? JH
sarah jayne says
OMG! I can’t believe you had such a bad time with this foundation 🙁 I personally absolutely love it, it really works for me. BUt you’re right, not every product works for everyone and I’m glad you didn’t pay full price if you weren’t happy with it. I’m curious about Double Wear, I’ve never tried it before and I think that maybe the next one on my shopping list!
plainsarahjayne xxx
hellojenniferhelen says
It’s definitely each to their own! Double Wear is my true love BUT I am so keen to try the Urban Decay All Nighter – I sampled it at the Urban NCL event and loved it. It’s on my shopping list!
? JH